Twenge thinks that smartphones are ruining children's lives. She talks about cell phone addiction and the mental health issues that correlate with it. Twenge also talks about how newer generations are almost forced into addiction “We didn’t have a choice to know any life without iPads or iPhones. I think we like our phones more than we like actual people". Twenge also discusses how smartphone scan lead to loneliness, and less interaction. Twenge writes a very opinionated piece and uses a lot of studies to back up her points. Cavanagh argues that the kids will be fine. She writes in a educational manner, and describes why Twenge's article lacks authenticity. Cavanagh states that all of the studies show similar outcomes, and were picked by Twenge, proving that Twenge's article isn't based off of proper research or studies. Both can agree that overuse of smartphones are not healthy for children and teens, however, they disagree on the long term affects cell phones may cause.
I first got my cellphone when I was eleven. My parents got it for me because I had a very busy dance schedule and often had to get rides from friends. They thought it was important for me to be able to communicate with them. Having a phone was a new found freedom. I was able to FaceTime, text, and watch YouTube videos. At the time I was not to addicted to my phone since I was busy with school and sports. However, when covid happened di became really addicted to my phone. It was the only way I could communicate with my friends. Since I was stuck in the house with nothing to do I often found myself scrolling on til Tok for hours. My average screen time during covid was about six hours a day. Post covid I have definitely gotten better about limiting my screen time however, I still struggle with putting my phone away once I am on it. I think If I had to give up my phone for a day, it would definitely be a weird adjustment. I think we all use our phones a lot more than we realize. I would need to find better ways to entertain myself. I think that it would be a good challenge, and I am going to try it this weekend!
I think that the lesson is that everything is fine in moderation. Cell phones are definitely not going away anytime soon, and so we must learn to limit our screen time and find hobbies and socialization outside of a screen. The use of data in an argument helps to validate your point, especially if your data is from a credible source. I think that incorporating outside data is important, because things like visuals and statistics help make your points easier for the reader to understand.